Pathological demand avoidance (PDA): Signs and impact

Reviewed by Agnes Ward, PhD, LP, CAADC, BCBA, LBA

Written by

therapist.com team

Last updated: 06/26/2025

Share this article

Share article

Share this article on Facebook Share this article on Twitter Share this article on LinkedIn Share this article on Messenger Share this article in email Copy the link to this article Print this article

What is pathological demand avoidance?

Pathological demand avoidance (PDA) involves an extreme avoidance of everyday demands, using strategies like distraction or surprising behavior.¹ Sometimes referred to as “pervasive drive for autonomy,” PDA is most often discussed in relation to children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), but adults can also experience these patterns of behavior.²

PDA is unique in that this avoidance isn’t limited to unpleasant tasks—it can extend to activities or requests the person might actually enjoy. People with PDA experience extreme distress when faced with demands—even those that might seem minor to others. This suggests that it’s the demands themselves, rather than the specific activities, that trigger distress.

The word “pathological” has faced criticism, with some researchers suggesting alternatives like “extreme” or “pervasive” demand avoidance.³ Critics argue that these terms better recognize avoidance behaviors as rational responses to overwhelming anxiety or stress, rather than truly pathological.

Pathological demand avoidance and autism spectrum disorder

PDA and ASD have a complex relationship. The debate continues about whether PDA is a separate condition or a subtype or trait that falls within the autism spectrum.⁴

PDA differs from “typical” presentations of ASD in a couple of key ways. Unlike many autistic individuals who respond well to structure and routine, people with PDA typically respond best to novelty, humor, and flexibility.⁵ Additionally, while structured support is often beneficial in ASD, people with PDA benefit more from one-to-one relationships that can help buffer demands.⁶

These differences have prompted researchers to examine how PDA fits within our understanding of ASD. Research suggests that PDA traits exist in varying concentrations within the autism spectrum, and some researchers propose that PDA may be more accurately understood as a collection of symptoms rather than a distinct condition.^7,8

Signs of pathological demand avoidance

There are no official pathological demand avoidance symptoms because it isn’t recognized as a standalone disorder in major diagnostic manuals like the DSM-5-TR or ICD-11.

Instead, PDA is recognized as a profile or trait that typically presents with several key behaviors:⁹

• Lasting resistance to everyday demands
• Using manipulation to avoid requests
• Having surface-level social skills without a normal sense of social identity 
• In children, a perception of being equal or superior to adults 
• Showing little pride or shame
• Behaving in ways that seem inappropriate or childish 
• Extreme impulsivity and rapid mood changes 
• Domineering or volatile behavior towards others
• Strong need for control 
• Early language delays
• Obsessive behavior focused on specific people or traits 
• Certain neurological issues (such as delayed milestones or seizures)

Children with PDA often don’t follow social norms or respect authority, sometimes behaving as though they have adult status.¹⁰ This can cause significant problems at school and within families, where children are expected to follow rules and respect authority figures.

Examples of pathological demand avoidance can look similar to many common behaviors that happen in childhood, such as:¹¹

• Resisting ordinary requests like putting on shoes, getting dressed, or completing assignments
• Only doing things when they want to, not when requested
• Making excuses, creating distractions, or having meltdowns when faced with demands

Only a clinician can provide proper assessment, diagnosis, and treatment recommendations. If you’re concerned about impulses or behaviors in yourself or someone you care about, consult a qualified mental health professional.

Pathological demand avoidance vs. ODD

PDA and oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) both involve resistance to demands. But an important difference is that children with ODD typically both respond to rewards and want to maintain their reputation with peers.¹²

In contrast, those with PDA may not respond to rewards because they see them as another form of control. They might also engage in behaviors that peers would find embarrassing. The underlying anxiety driving PDA behaviors is also a key difference from the more defiant nature of ODD.

Causes and risk factors for pathological demand avoidance

Research suggests that anxiety and trouble handling uncertainty are significant predictors of PDA behaviors.¹³ For many people with PDA, demands cause extreme anxiety. Avoiding these demands may be an attempt to manage that stress.

One study found that in adult populations, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms, emotional instability, and uncooperative behavior were strong predictors of PDA behaviors.¹⁴ This suggests that multiple factors could play a role in how demand-avoidant patterns begin and continue.

How PDA impacts daily life

PDA can significantly impact education.¹⁵ Many children struggle to access appropriate support for their behavioral challenges. In some cases, the distress and burnout caused by demand avoidance can be so overwhelming that they feel unable to attend school.¹⁶ As a result, they may feel excluded by their peers or even be expelled from school.

Beyond education, PDA presents significant challenges to families. Parental reports suggest that traditional parenting techniques (involving clear boundaries and reward systems) often do not work with PDA.¹⁷ Some parents reported that following advice from parenting trainings actually made their child’s difficulties worse.

Parents and caregivers may experience distress from witnessing their child, or the person they care for, in pain.¹⁸ They may become exhausted from constantly trying to find effective ways to reduce, disguise, or remove demands. They may also face ongoing stress and frustration when trying to access support in areas such as diagnosis, education, mental health, and social care.

Pathological demand avoidance treatment options

PDA is not a formally recognized diagnosis, which means there’s no standard diagnostic criteria for it. Clinicians may use the Extreme Demand Avoidance Questionnaire (EDA-Q) to help identify PDA and guide treatment planning.¹⁹

While PDA and autism are often linked, treatment strategies for PDA often differ from the ones recommended for ASD.²⁰ For instance, instead of focusing on rewards and consequences, children with PDA may benefit from flexibility training. This might involve developing skills like making a plan B, compromising, and learning to identify “no-choice” situations.

For adults with PDA who are also diagnosed with ASD, there’s some evidence that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based interventions can help address the underlying anxiety that appears to drive demand avoidance.²¹ However, more research is needed to confirm effectiveness.

Supporting someone with PDA

When it comes to supporting a friend or loved one with PDA, a “low-demand, low-arousal” approach is often effective.²² This may look like reducing or removing demands whenever possible, offering choices, using indirect language, and turning requests into games. ²³

Allowing the person more control over their environment and avoiding things that may cause stress—like too much eye contact, touching, or confrontation—can also help. If someone is upset, it’s best to give them space or move them to a quieter area.

Other helpful strategies include identifying triggers for demand avoidance, managing and disguising demands, and creating a sensory-friendly environment. Some people also benefit from therapy, mindfulness, or meditation to help manage anxiety and emotions.

If someone you care about is struggling with demand avoidance behaviors, help is available. Visit our therapist directory to connect with a licensed mental health professional near you.